“I don’t read Reason magazine.”
-Mitch “Cut and Paste” Daniels
NO, that’s not Reason’s ad campaign for this fall, though the way things are going they might consider it; it’s former genius Mitch Daniels trying to extricate himself from the plagiarism scandal he started while trying to extricate himself from last week’s book burning scandal.
Evidently Daniels released a statement last week which seems to’ve borrowed copiously from two publications: yet another anti-Zinn obit from 2010 in Reason, and a press release from Stanford concerning Professor Sam Wineburg critique of Zinn. The Wineburg quote was later excised from Daniels’ statement, after Wineburg complained, saying, “I have criticized Zinn but will defend to my death the right to teach him. Shame on Mitch Daniels,” on the Twitter thing.
Excerpt of Daniels’ first statement defending his criticism of history Howard Zinn, sent to reporters on July 17: “No one need take my word that my concerns were well-founded. Respected scholars and communicators of all ideologies agree that the work of Howard Zinn was irredeemably slanted and unsuited for teaching to schoolchildren. “Arthur M. Schlesinger said, ‘I don’t take him very seriously. He’s a polemicist, not a historian.’ Socialist historian Michael Kazin judged Zinn’s work as ‘bad history, albeit tilted with virtuous intentions’ and said the book was more suited to a ‘conspiracy monger’s website than to a work of scholarship.’ Reviewing the text in The American Scholar, Harvard University professor Oscar Handlin denounced ‘the deranged quality of his fairy tale, in which the incidents are made to fit the legend, no matter how intractable the evidence of American history.’ “Stanford history education expert Sam Wineburg cautioned that exposing children to a heavily filtered and weighted interpretation such as Zinn’s work is irresponsible when ‘we are talking about how we educate the young, those who do not yet get the interpretive game.’ “Many more such condemnations by persons of political viewpoints different from my own are available on request.”
Excerpt of Michael Moynihan’s Reason magazine article 2010: “Much of the criticism of Zinn has come from dissenters on the left. Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. once remarked that ‘I don’t take him very seriously. He’s a polemicist, not a historian.’ Last year, the liberal historian Sean Wilentz referred to the ‘balefully influential works of Howard Zinn.’ Reviewing A People’s History in The American Scholar, Harvard University professor Oscar Handlin denounced ‘the deranged quality of his fairy tale, in which the incidents are made to fit the legend, no matter how intractable the evidence of American history.’ Socialist historian Michael Kazin judged Zinn’s most famous work ‘bad history, albeit gilded with virtuous intentions.’”
Excerpt from 2012 Stanford University press release quoting Stanford education professor Sam Wineburg on Howard Zinn’s work: “Wineburg writes that a heavily filtered and weighted interpretation becomes dangerous when ‘we are talking about how we educate the young, those who do not yet get the interpretive game.’”
Excerpt of Daniels’ statement, still dated July 17, as it appeared on Purdue University’s website Tuesday: “No one need take my word that my concerns were well founded. Respected scholars and communicators of all ideologies agree that the work of Howard Zinn was irredeemably slanted and unsuited for teaching to schoolchildren. Arthur M. Schlesinger said, “I don’t take him very seriously. He’s a polemicist, not a historian.” Many more such condemnations by persons of political viewpoints different from my own are available on request.”Anyone who’s ever graded a paper recognizes the technique. It’s not even a question. It’s sloppy, at best, and it wasn’t at the service of convincing the paper-grader you’d read the assignment; this was the President of a major uni…, I mean, Purdue, trying to defend an idea he shouldn’t have had in the first place. (Not to mention one which, as we noted last week, he rather obviously didn’t have before he read Sneering Haberdashery Republican Roger Kimball’s Zinn obit in the National Review. That led Daniels to tell his henchmen that there were “errors on every page” of A People’s History.)
So we had Mitch Daniels trying to use the power of the state to censor teachers, and professors, over a book he’d only heard described, and which wasn’t in use anywhere among Indiana public schools, insisting, first, that he was only speaking of secondary schools even though the entire conversation revolved around changing standards for an education degree, then taking examples from two pieces in order to prove that Zinn had been criticized. By Even the Liberal Arthur Schlessinger, Jr. Of course he had to swipe examples. How was he supposed to sound like he knew what he was talking about?
By the way, this is the eight-year history of the state of Indiana under Daniels’ governorship. Except for the part where he gets called out for what he said and did.
Like his online statements, P. U. President Mitch Daniels grows shorter and shorter over time.
Seeing that South US 666 roadsign reminded me of this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Route_491
I had travelled the 'Devil's Highway' more than once, usually en route to Canyonlands.
I think Mitch only took the Purdue job so he could practice hearing "President Daniels," and godamighty, doesn't the sound of that give you the willies. But since hypocritical, plagiarizing, anti-intellectual, contentless idiocy is a feature-not-a-bug in the Republican run for the roses, he should score some points. I wonder if the fact that smart people won't be sending their smart kids to Purdue and all our bridges will collapse when stupider engineers start graduating will make any of them rethink this decision. Actually, I don't really wonder that.
You’ll Never Believe It
You're right. I don't.
I sure wish the AP could get to the emails on a whole range of debacles and asset sales but I'm not holding my breath. Come on AP. Ask for more!
Good recommendation is usually bound to become ignored, other then that is no motive to not provides it.model jaket kulit korea murah di bali
jual jaket murah model harley dari riau
trend jaket kulit polos murah ala papua
wow it is outstanding stuff, love it simply Adopt a dog
The whole movie is an unendurable combination of cliches that don't add up or become interesting at any point. The discretely repeated attempts at delivering overused social messages makes it even worse. Even those messages are shallow in content, irrelevant to the movie and extremely unoriginal just as the story itself. rampage 2018
I hoped during the movie that it would get better at some point but it went just worse. For those who are aware of these issues this is just a pretentious attempt and for the rest they don't care or won't get that message from a movie like this one. devil's candy
I witnessed one of the worst movies of all times. You can't blame a movie for receiving an award but this clearly shows the demise of the movie industry as such movies can be produced and nominated and awarded just because of the exploitation of the social issues, and juries getting revenge and amplify the message with their own means. watch Avengers: Infinity War free online Engineering the marketing of overrated films became the norm.Oscar winning motion pictures often became classics now they are not even worth a second view. This one doesn't even deserve to be watched.
nice work Well-done I appreciate your workfor your great work in progress 🎁
Good published. Thank a lot for this helpful blog. Photo Editing Guide
Web Image Editing
Neck Joint Service
Cut Out Background
Neck Joint Tutorial
Hello really awesome web site!! Guy .. Beautiful .. Wonderful .. I’ll bookmark your site and consider the feeds moreover. I am pleased to search out beneficial details appropriate here inside of the published material, thanks for sharing…
What is an outstanding post! “I’ll be back” (to read more of your content). Thanks for the nudge!
I can’t imagine focusing long enough to research; much less write this kind of article. You’ve outdone yourself with this material. This is great content.
The post was really very good. Thanks for sharing.
Amazing! Its really amazing article, I have got much clear idea regarding
from this post. 온라인경마
I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a piece of great information that is actually helpful. Good day! 스포츠토토
Thanks for sharing with us this important Content. I feel strongly about it and really enjoyed learning more about this topic.
I’ve a project that I am just now working on, and I have been on the look out for such information. 먹튀검증
What a nice post! I'm so happy to read this. 토토사이트추천 What you wrote was very helpful to me. Thank you. Actually, I run a site similar to you. If you have time, could you visit my site? Please leave your comments after reading what I wrote. If you do so, I will actively reflect your opinion. I think it will be a great help to run my site. Have a good day.
Post a Comment